CBS ‘The Young And The Restless’ (Y&R) spoilers show that there are plenty of theories spinning around out there about Amanda Sinclair (Mishael Morgan), her past, and who she really is. Some fan theories pit her as the late Hilary Curtis who has seemingly come back from the dead. While it’s a little hard to believe, it is a soap opera and they could find a way to make this a reality.
However, the seemingly more possible reality is that Hilary and Amanda were twins who were separated at birth. Hilary got to live her life seemingly normal while Amanda bounced through foster care and eventually ended up in Genoa City by chance or twin intuition.
Now someone has thought about the chance that Amanda is actually Hilary, not the one that died, but the real Hilary. Perhaps this is how they got mixed up on the date of their birth. So, what would this change?
https://www.instagram.com/p/CEsMojoJ99i/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link
CBS ‘The Young And The Restless’ Spoilers: Fan Theory Suggests Amanda And Hilary Were Mixed Up At Birth! – Hilary Was Actually Amanda!
This is what one fan thinks, “I was thinking that Amanda and Hillary were mixed up at birth and Amanda was the one who died and this is actually Hillary!”. While at first, this sounds super interesting, I’m not so sure it would really make a difference, would it?
It could explain why they were separated at birth, and maybe they went the wrong ways, but it would just be a name change right? I mean, Devon Hamilton (Bryton James) still loved and married who he did, if she was actually Amanda, it wouldn’t change the fact that her “long lost twin” is now in Genoa City.
I think it’s an interesting thought, and anything would be better than bringing Hilary back from the dead. That old thing gets tiring.
What do you think? Do you like this fan theory? Let us know in the comments below.
‘Young and the Restless’ weekdays on the CBS network. Check your local listings for times. In the meantime, let us know what you think by leaving us a line with your thoughts in our comments section below.
And as always, come back to Daily Soap Dish for all the latest news on your favorite celebrities and reality television shows along with the latest spoilers from The Bold and the Beautiful, The Young and the Restless, General Hospital, and Days of Our Lives. Don’t forget to visit TVRocker for all of the latest exciting news on all of your favorite daytime television soaps.